Do ant colonies get less likely to die with age? A 34-year study finds 'negative senescence' in harvester ants
On about 30 hectares of desert in Mesa County, Colorado, live on average some 1,270 colonies of the western harvester ant (Pogonomyrmex occidentalis). Since 1992 two researchers have gone back every year to tag, map and measure each colony and to note which have newly appeared and which have gone. Of the colonies already standing in 1992, 51 were still alive in 2024, at an estimated age of about 41.
From 3,285 colonies of known age, the authors find that from age two, when a colony can first reproduce, its yearly risk of dying falls as it gets older, while its chance of sending out new queens or males in the mating season rises, though ever more slowly. This reversal of the usual pattern is called negative senescence. The authors checked that it is not simply a matter of weak colonies dying young and leaving the robust ones behind: how fast a colony grew early on explained almost none of the variation in lifespan.
What makes this possible, they argue, is a body that can be replaced wholesale. A queen can live for decades but her workers last about a year, so the ants doing the foraging and nursing are just as young in a 30-year-old colony as in a one-year-old one; the authors compare this to a deciduous tree putting out fresh leaves each year. Colonies also keep growing, bigger colonies die less often and reproduce more often, and colonies that had grown more over the previous year were more likely, not less, to reproduce, so there was no sign that growth is paid for in reproduction.
The environment is part of the argument too. At this site the share of colonies reproducing in a given year ranged from under a tenth to nearly four-fifths, and the number of new colonies appearing the following year from 23 to more than 250, yet the two were uncorrelated; the authors argue that such unpredictability favours colonies that live long and reproduce again and again. They also point out that earlier studies of another harvester ant, Pogonomyrmex barbatus, and of the red imported fire ant (Solenopsis invicta) found colony mortality patterns closer to ordinary ageing, so this is not a rule for all ants.
People age. Cats and dogs age. So do most insects: the older they get, the more likely they are to die. But scientists in Colorado who tracked more than three thousand colonies of the western harvester ant (Pogonomyrmex occidentalis) for 34 years found that these colonies did the reverse. The older a colony was, the less likely it was to die out, and the more often it produced the next generation of queens and males.
The key may be that a colony never stops growing, and that growing does not come at the expense of reproducing. The paper's title speaks of a 'replaceable soma', that is, a replaceable body. This means the workers: a queen can live for decades, but workers live only about a year and are replaced as they die. It is a bit like a sports team whose veterans retire and rookies step in while the team itself keeps getting stronger.
DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2612817123

